Full List of TV Shows Canceled in 2025 (So Far) Full List of TV Shows Canceled in 2025 (So Far)
Full List of TV Shows That Canceled and Renewedin May 2025 Full List of TV Shows That Canceled and Renewedin May 2025

Peacock has made major programming changes ahead of the 2025-2026 television season, officially canceling four shows: Mr. Throwback, Based on a True Story, Hysteria!, and Teacup. As confirmed by Vulture and Variety, most of these cancellations hit newer series and comedies, signaling a strategic shift at the streaming platform.

Below is a detailed breakdown of each canceled show and the reasons behind their termination.

Full List of Peacock TV Shows Canceled Ahead of 2025-2026
Peacock Cancelled 4 TV Shows Ahead Of 2025-2026 Season

1. Based on a True Story

Seasons: 2

Starring: Kaley Cuoco, Chris Messina

Premiering in 2023, "Based on a True Story" followed Ava and Nathan Bartlett, a married couple who collaborate with a serial killer to create a true-crime podcast. The dark comedy-drama quickly gained attention thanks to its sharp writing and star power. Despite running for two seasons, the series ended on a cliffhanger, leaving fans frustrated by the sudden cancellation.

Reason for Cancellation: Peacock has not publicly shared detailed viewership numbers, but reports suggest that the show's audience engagement declined after its debut season. Combined with rising production costs and a broader trend of platforms tightening budgets, the network decided to cut the series.

2. Mr. Throwback

Seasons: 1

Starring: Ego Nwodim, Ayden Mayeri, Adam Pally, Stephen Curry (as himself)

"Mr. Throwback" told the story of a struggling sports memorabilia dealer trying to pay off his debts to the Polish mafia by reconnecting with his childhood friends. Mixing sports culture with comedic storytelling, the show brought a fresh concept to Peacock's lineup.

Reason for Cancellation: Despite a unique premise and the draw of NBA superstar Stephen Curry, "Mr. Throwback" failed to generate significant buzz. Critics noted that the humor felt inconsistent, and audience retention was reportedly low. Budget reallocation toward more mainstream titles also factored into its cancellation.

3. Teacup

Seasons: 1

Starring: Yvonne Strahovski, Scott Speedman, Chaske Spencer

Adapted from Robert R. McCammon's novel Stinger, "Teacup" was a horror series set on a remote Georgia ranch under siege by a mysterious threat. The show combined survival horror with psychological tension, offering a different flavor compared to typical network fare.

Reason for Cancellation: Horror shows often struggle to maintain consistent viewership unless they become breakout hits. "Teacup" received mixed reviews from critics, who praised its atmosphere but criticized its pacing. With mounting competition in the horror genre, Peacock opted not to continue with a second season.

4. Hysteria!

Seasons: 1

Starring: Emjay Anthony, Chiara Aurelia, Bruce Campbell, Julie Bowen

Set against the backdrop of the 1980s "Satanic Panic," "Hysteria!" was a horror-comedy exploring mass hysteria and cultural paranoia. Despite its nostalgic setting and strong cast, the series struggled to find its footing.

Reason for Cancellation: Audience response was lukewarm. While the idea intrigued some viewers, critics pointed to tonal inconsistencies and a lack of narrative focus. Peacock ultimately decided that "Hysteria!" did not justify the cost of continuation.

Conclusion: What Peacock's Cancellations Mean

Peacock's decision to cancel these four shows signals a more cautious content strategy heading into 2025-2026. With an increased focus on proven franchises, broader-appeal series, and major event programming, niche and experimental shows are facing a tougher battle for renewal.

While the cancellations are disappointing for fans, they reflect larger industry trends of consolidation and a stronger focus on content with guaranteed audience returns. For viewers, it means being prepared for shorter show runs and the possibility of more abrupt endings in the streaming era.

Top 10 Most Popular TV Networks in the U.S Top 10 Most Popular TV Networks in the U.S

Changes in American television viewership over the last year have been substantial. This article takes a close look at the ten most watched television networks ...
CBS Midseason 2025 Premieres Dates: Highlights, and Full Lineup CBS Midseason 2025 Premieres Dates: Highlights, and Full Lineup

As we enter the midseason of 2025, CBS is gearing up to captivate audiences with a well-rounded lineup of gripping dramas, laugh-out-loud comedies, reality staples, ...
CBS Cancels 6 Shows for 2025-2026: Full List and Key Reasons CBS Cancels 6 Shows for 2025-2026: Full List and Key Reasons

CBS cancels six TV shows for the 2025-2026 season. Discover the full list, reasons behind the cuts, and what CBS's next moves reveal about the ...
Who Is Scott Pelley? ‘60 Minutes’ Host Who Boldly Attacked CBS Parent Company On Air Who Is Scott Pelley? ‘60 Minutes’ Host Who Boldly Attacked CBS Parent Company On Air

Legendary '60 Minutes' host Scott Pelley shocked viewers by publicly criticizing CBS parent company Paramount Global over editorial interference. Discover his full biography, career highlights, ...